Skip to main content
Home
  • English
  • Français

User account menu

  • Log in

Secondary Menu

  • Home
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us

Social Menu

  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
Content type
Item language

Manage your member accounts  |  Advanced search

  • About Us
    • Mission and Vision
    • Strategic Plan
    • Our Commitment to Reconciliation
    • Our History
    • Who we are
      • Our Structure
      • Our Chapters
        • Newfoundland & Labrador
        • Prince Edward Island
        • Nova Scotia
        • New Brunswick
        • Quebec
        • National Capital
        • Ontario
        • Manitoba
        • Saskatchewan
        • Alberta and Northwest Territories
        • British Columbia
        • Yukon
      • Board and Secretariat
      • Our Committees, Working Groups and Task Forces
      • Volunteer opportunities
    • Our Fellowship
    • Advocacy
    • Partnerships
      • Canadian Partners
      • International Partnerships
    • CES Awards
    • Our Policies
  • Membership
    • Why Become a CES Member
    • Member Discounts and Benefits
    • Join the CES
    • Membership Fees
    • Renew Your Membership
  • Latest News
    • Latest News
    • Upcoming National and Chapter Events
  • Designations
    • About the CE Designation
    • Competencies for Canadian Evaluators
    • Roster of Credentialed Evaluators
    • Credentialed Evaluator Success Stories
    • For Candidates
    • For Credentialed Evaluators
    • For Employers and Purchasers
    • For Educators and Trainers
    • For Other Professional Societies
  • Professional Learning
    • e-Institute
    • Webinars (members)
      • Registration
      • Webinars - Frequently Asked Questions
    • Non-CES Events (members only)
    • Submit a Non-CES event
    • Annual Conference
    • Mentoring Initiative
    • Student Competitions
    • Educational Fund
    • Post-secondary Courses
  • CJPE
    • CJPE Book Club Webinars
    • CJPE Introduction
    • Issues and Articles
    • Search for an Article
    • Submit a Manuscript to the CJPE
  • Resources
    • What Is Evaluation?
    • Ethics
    • Program Evaluation Standards
    • Submit an Unpublished Document
    • Jobs, Contracts, Collaborations (members only)
    • Add a Job, Contract, or Collaboration Opportunity
    • Standards to Support Classroom Assessment

Impact = Content x Influence: A Paper from the CES Past President

You are here:

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
17 Nov
2016
Tags
Journals
Evaluative Voices
CES Past President

A recent article was published in the Evaluative Voices series of the Northern Institute (NI), Charles Darwin University (CDU), entitled Impact = Content x Influence: Evaluation, evidence and policy in Canadian Government and written by Benoît Gauthier (CE; Honorary Fellow, NI/CDU; Past President, CES; Treasurer, IOCE). In the paper, Gauthier makes three points: there is no such thing as evidence-based policy-making, anywhere; the Canadian infrastructure for evidence-based policy-making is complex; and in the dynamic of policy-making, although evidence is only a small part of the equation there are factors that can increase the likelihood of evidence use.

Gauthier presents the equation impact (of evidence on policy) = content x influence. Content refers to the quantity x quality x access x congruency of the evidence and influence includes the components of credibility x congruency x timeliness x self-scrutiny x expediency.

Using these concepts, Gauthier outlines ways that evidence producers, including evaluators, can increase the impact of evidence on policy-making:

  1. plan more systematic data collection and more rigorous study designs to connect the problem with potential solutions (quality of content);
  2. develop more information on the problem situation and its dynamics (quantity of content);
  3. prepare pre-packaged syntheses of information on the problem (accessibility of content);
  4. present the evidence in a manner that connects with the preconceived notions held by the decision makers (congruency of content);
  5. route the evidence through an interest group or a brain trust that has the decision maker’s ear (credibility and congruency of the source);
  6. conduct strategic analysis of the policy landscape to forecast when a social problem will surface in the decision maker’s agenda and ensure the availability of required evidence in time (timeliness of evidence);
  7. select battles that can be won and move on when the decision maker is not open to evidence information (self-scrutiny of the decision-maker); and/or
  8. identify the information that is most likely to feed the public policy debate in the direction of evidence informed decision making (expediency of the evidence).

In This Section

  • About Us
    • Mission and Vision
    • Strategic Plan
    • Our Commitment to Reconciliation
    • Our History
    • Who we are
    • Our Fellowship
    • Advocacy
    • Partnerships
    • CES Awards
    • Our Policies
  • Membership
    • Why Become a CES Member
    • Member Discounts and Benefits
    • Join the CES
    • Membership Fees
    • Renew Your Membership
  • Latest News
    • Latest News
    • Upcoming National and Chapter Events
  • Designations
    • About the CE Designation
    • Competencies for Canadian Evaluators
    • Roster of Credentialed Evaluators
    • Credentialed Evaluator Success Stories
    • For Candidates
    • For Credentialed Evaluators
    • For Employers and Purchasers
    • For Educators and Trainers
    • For Other Professional Societies
  • Professional Learning
    • e-Institute
    • Webinars (members)
    • Non-CES Events (members only)
    • Submit a Non-CES event
    • Annual Conference
    • Mentoring Initiative
    • Student Competitions
    • Educational Fund
    • Post-secondary Courses
  • CJPE
    • CJPE Book Club Webinars
    • CJPE Introduction
    • Issues and Articles
    • Search for an Article
    • Submit a Manuscript to the CJPE
  • Resources
    • What Is Evaluation?
    • Ethics
    • Program Evaluation Standards
    • Submit an Unpublished Document
    • Jobs, Contracts, Collaborations (members only)
    • Add a Job, Contract, or Collaboration Opportunity
    • Standards to Support Classroom Assessment

Tags

20182019CESCES ConferenceCESEFCongrès de la SCÉFSCÉÉJournalsMember servicesRevuesSCEServices aux membres
more tags

Recent Opportunity Posting

Either you are not logged in or no opportunity is active right now.

Upcoming Events

  • Webinar | Be Fearlessly Engaging
  • Webinar | Be Fearlessly Engaging
  • Supporting Equitable Evaluation: Practical Insights for Data Collection Processes

Latest Publications

  • Nominations Open for the Contribution to Evaluation in Canada Award
  • Nominations Open for the Service to CES Award
  • Upcoming System Downtime: February 9 to 14

Contact Details

180 Plaunt St. S, Suite 3
Renfrew, Ontario
K7V 1M8

Phone: 1-855-251-5721
Fax: 613-432-6840

Contact Us

© Copyright 2014 by Canadian Evaluation Society. All Rights Reserved. Privacy and DisclaimerDesign by baytek systems